Pages

Showing posts with label Systemic Thinking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Systemic Thinking. Show all posts

Wednesday, 25 June 2014

Left wing? Right wing? It’s complex.

In ‘The Origin of Wealth’ (see initial review here), Beinhocker has a long section where he applies his ideas about complexity and evolutionary economics to more practical contexts. He’s a McKinsey man, so one is obviously business strategy and organisation. Another is politics, where his ambitions are humble: “the Complexity approach to economics has the potential to make the historical framing of politics obsolete”. And we aren’t just talking “mushy” (his word) Third Way, New Labour pragmatic populism here.

"Nail them, even at personal cost to yourself" credit: SenorGif
He characterises the dominant Left-Right distinction as based on two disagreements: 1) how to view human nature (Left: humans are essentially altruistic and bad things are society’s fault vs. Right: humans are essentially selfish and pursuing self-interest is an inalienable right). And 2) the role of states vs. markets. According to complexity economics in both cases they are both wrong. On human nature, it turns out we are “conditional co-operators and altruistic punishers,” that is to say we operate according to a (hilariously) modified Golden Rule of: “do unto others as you would have them do unto you... but if others don’t do unto you, then nail them, even at personal cost to yourself”. Which has an intuitive resonance given my childhood Monopoly-playing experiences. Anyway, that nugget should be the foundation of policymaking (and Beinhocker shows how in welfare debates, for example), not outmoded conceptions based on Left/Right distinctions.

More interesting are his ideas about states and markets. I’m summarising horribly but basically, strong government intervention in the economy as advocated by the Left is misguided because, 1) faced with the vast complexity of the economy, human rationality is hopelessly inadequate - as Orgel’s Second Rule states “evolution is cleverer than you are,” so don’t try to be a market. And 2) if the arbiter of economic fitness is some politician or party at the centre (in Beinhocker's terms, 'Big Man') then the economy is likely to start to orientate itself towards promoting the interest of that politician or party. On the other hand, the Right's fantasy of unadulterated markets existing in pristine isolation is equally misguided, because the market as part of the economic evolutionary system is constructed out of a vast array of Social Technologies, comprising institutions, norms etc., many of which rely on government. The complexity solution? States help shape the ‘economic fitness function’ (= what we value and want the economy to work towards) whilst markets carry out the job of differentiating, selecting and amplifying Business plans according to this fitness function.

So what, expressing things in terms of complexity doesn't remove the niggly problems and trade-offs that are inevitable in politics, right? This is my initial feeling - taking the example above, to be honest at this point, pretty much everyone in the political mainstream agrees that states and markets both have an important role to play, so the caricatured socialist Left and free-market Right that Beinhocker slays aren't the issue. But complexity's basic insight that micro-behaviour matters for the operation of the system as a whole could be key. In fact Beinhocker suggests that it's here that we can find the answer to persistent poverty: in the norms guiding individuals’ behaviour (i.e. culture), which means that the usual prescriptions of the Left (redistribution) and the Right (laissez-faire, individual incentives) won't solve the problem. Some of the stuff he says about national cultures I am immediately wary of (anyone citing Samuel Huntington’s ‘clash of civilisations’ gets my alarm bells ringing), but otherwise it seems plausible.

I had a little rummage around Google Scholar and apparently the above paragraph sums things up more or less: according to Paul Cairney at the University of Aberdeen (gated, apologies), some people think that Complexity Theory in politics is a passing fad, whilst others gibber unintelligibly about a ‘paradigm shift’ (*ahem*). Getting concrete remains the issue: ‘mapping the landscape’, ‘modelling the struggle’ and ‘encouraging systemic emergence’ all sound wonderful but are basically unintelligible. Add in a greater use of trial and error, learning from pilot projects, and accepting a degree of ‘error’ when designing policies instead of seeing error as ‘failure’ and we’re getting closer to 'Monday morning' realities, but still vague.

Great, but what does it mean in practice? credit: http://thewildpeak.wordpress.com/


Specifics are in short supply, so as a conclusion I’ll veer hazily back to fun, broad, sweeping ideas. If evolution is super clever at sorting through designs to get the best one, we need to bring evolutionary processes inside political decision-making somehow. Duncan Green spells out the implications: “we need to find a way of designing and strengthening institutions to make non-market forms of selection and amplification as effective as possible”. And this means nibbling away at the margins at the goals of individual agents, the norms that guide behaviour and the feedback loops in the system.

This all amounts to saying that the answers remain very much unclear. But at least we have a new question: no longer “Left versus Right” but rather “how best to evolve?”

Friday, 6 June 2014

Complexity meets economics: from caveman to the present today in three easy steps

“Wealth is knowledge and its origin is evolution”

Hark, those of you who don’t know about economics but would like to, or those who know about economics but are dissatisfied with the Neoclassical mainstream. Read this book. In fact, anyone who thinks about politics, business or development or anything should read it too, because it will fling open new mental doors (leading to complexity theory and other fun things).

In 450 compelling pages (hah), Beinhocker uses evolution theory to sketch out sometimes mindblowing answers to the basic questions of ‘what is wealth?’ and ‘how can it be increased?’. First of all, he meticulously sweeps away the Traditional economics which has so conspicuously failed in recent years, with its ridiculous assumptions like perfect rationality and fixation on the concept of equilibrium. Apparently it got lost in 19th century physics and forgot that “if the universe cannot escape the Second Law [of Thermodynamics], then neither can economics”. Instead, he shows how wealth is knowledge, emerging from a simple evolutionary algorithm: differentiate, select and amplify. Essentially, what biological evolution does for genes and living organisms, economic evolution does for business plans (broadly defined) and companies. As Beinhocker himself puts it, evolution says: “I will try lots of things and see what works and do more of what works and less of what doesn’t”. And the result of this ‘deductive-tinkering’? A complex adaptive system (‘explained’ in an earlier post so I won’t bore you here) which doubled world per capita GDP to $180 in the 15 000 years to 1750 AD, then in the following 250 years increased it 37 fold.


Because blurry tables explain things better than I do.
Going beyond parsing the intro, it’s a book that makes you challenge how we instinctively conceptualise the world around us. How often is it that you’ve heard a Business defined as “a person, or an organized group of people, who transforms matter, energy and information from one state into another with the goal of making a profit”? It’s rewarding but hard, thinking in systems, and not because you’re stupid; it’s “just that our brains are not wired to think this way”. Beinhocker also produces new, or at least unfamiliar terminology for his cast of evolutionary characters, from ‘Physical and Social Technologies’, to the ‘evolutionary design space’ to ‘schema readers’. But it’s done in an accessible way - at one point he uses the analogy of a toddler making Lego figures – and even with the occasional amusing anecdote: who knew that the Italian economist Pareto “spent his later years as a recluse in a Swiss mountain chalet with twenty angora cats”?

So an economics that can take us from caveman to the present day, and which does not depend on ironing out our humanity to make its models work. And with lessons for business strategy (think portfolio of experiments not taking a big bet), organisations, policymakers, and anyone who wants to effect change. Even nearly 10 years since it was first published, these are ideas that still haven’t broken through into the mainstream, as Kate Raworth recently pointed out. But it’s an exciting time for thinking, when the ground is shifting beneath your feet.

More to come on this, for sure, but for now, read the book.

Credit: cheezburger.com


Saturday, 26 April 2014

Emergent Thoughts on Emergence

Just finished ‘Aid on the Edge of Chaos’ by Ben Ramalingam, which applies ideas about complex adaptive systems to aid and development. Though ‘finished’ wouldn’t be quite the right word, as I reckon I’ll need about four more readings to get close to understanding the content. As the title suggests, this will be more a provisional set of conclusions.
Conventional development thinking: 'whoops'
credit www.drsalonen.com
I’ve already written about how Ramalingam critiques the current mode of thinking in development but it’s worth repeating the basic point: we need to stop applying simplistic analyses to complex problems. Ideas derived from Newtonian physics aren’t able to fully describe the totality of our social, environmental, ecological, political and economic reality. Who knew? Actually, the observation that the world is complex is so obvious that I can’t believe we’ve managed to fool ourselves into thinking that you can reduce REALITY to a few squares on a log-frame all this time. 

Upshot: as Abraham Lincoln says, "we must disenthrall ourselves" (one of many, many brilliant quotes in the book).

One part of this disenthralling is to stop looking for panaceas in development. Owen Barder recounts them nicely for us: more capital, more savings, more aid, more technology, better policies, better institutions, better politics. In fact, the desire for panaceas is itself part of the problem. And no, thinking in terms of complex adaptive systems is not the panacea either. This might seem obvious: accepting that there isn’t one solution to the problem of achieving development sounds easy, but actually our brains have a sneaky tendency to slip back into that way of thinking. This came home to me listening to a podcast in preparation for this post (it’s sad but I actually do prepare); Humanosphere editor Tom Paulson, when interviewing Owen Barder, asked him whether complexity thinking means that we need to look at tax havens to achieve development. Barder: that’s exactly the type of panacea thinking we are trying to get away from. Yeah.

So what are complex adaptive systems/systems of organised complexity? Let me throw some words at you that together constitute a vague approximation to an answer. Complex adaptive systems have large numbers of mutually interacting parts, are open to the environment, are self-organising in their internal structure, have ‘emergent’ macroscopic properties over and above the properties of their constitutive parts (think human consciousness as more than putting together feet and white blood cells and nerves and lungs). Complex systems are interconnected and interdependent and dynamic, constantly evolving and adapting. From all that I’m sure it’s apparent that I don’t totally understand either. Looking at the box might be helpful at this point. In fact Ramalingam takes pains to emphasise that complexity thinking is itself a work in progress even for people who research it, so don’t feel bad.

Comparison of conventional aid thinking and complexity-influenced ideas about development

Okay so that’s all well and interesting that clever people have found out why everyone’s been wrong for the last seventy years but what does it mean for development? Ramalingam provides some broad-brush messages on this: complexity thinking can’t tell you what to do on Monday morning, but it can help us understand the world around us better, promote more open debate about the challenges facing us, and help us think up new approaches to problems. It can help us “see through new eyes”. In this sense, development is more of an emergent property of a society/economy rather than a outcome of a process to be engineered. Aid in an ideal world then becomes “an open innovation network,” an “internal catalyst...[to] identify, expand and sustain the space for change,” a “fluid, dynamic, emergent” process. We stop looking for ‘the answer’ because, as the NYU Development Research Institute strapline goes, “there are no answers for global poverty. There are only answer-finding systems.” If nothing else, you can’t say complexity thinking isn’t good at snappy one-liners.

The thrill from this enormous potential is kind of feeding into my disillusionment with NGO work at the moment; the organisations I have experienced thus far are not embedded in the relevant 'system', not looking to foster small adaptive changes whilst accepting the underlying complexity of the problem they are trying to address. The organisations I have worked for have their ‘product’ with its own intellectual framework which is superimposed onto a given situation. They have their own thinking, activities and feedback loops which are only tangentially aligned with the problem at hand with all its complexity, non-linear characteristics and emergent properties. And most dangerous of all, they are self-sustaining, insulated from their own inadequacies by the current aid system.

Ramalingam shows us complex systems thinking in action: it’s all over the place apparently, from emergent leadership in Obama’s election campaign, to holistic range management in Zimbabwe, to conflict resolution in Aceh after the Boxing Day tsunami, to the development of M-Pesa mobile money in Kenya. The book is filled with examples.

After the above whirlwind, I’m still left with a few questions though:
  • How do you identify a system? What is the scale of a system?
  • How do you know when something is not a problem of organized complexity?
  • What would development institutions/donors/NGOs look like if you took them apart and rebuilt them to be equipped to face problems of complexity?
  • What are the steps to changing aid in the right direction? Is it just that we read Ramalingam's book, realise we’ve been doing it wrong and change our approach? How do you change the system? (Ramalingam recognises the difficulties of this with the remark that “thousands of careers depend on sustaining certain ways of looking at the world”. That'd be politics again.)

Time to read it again I guess.

Thursday, 13 March 2014

The Rebirth of Education (part 2): best bits

In part 1 I gave a quick run-down of Lant Pritchett's 'The Rebirth of Education'. In six words, learning not schooling, starfish not spider. Now I thought I'd highlight some important and/or interesting take-home messages. They mostly buzz around the same theme but hopefully will crystallise things a little.

On the problem:

1) You can't solve the education problem if you don't understand it.

We need to grasp that schooling systems adopted in developing countries were not designed to enable children to meet learning goals, so more of the same (more inputs alone) doesn't cut it. As with an addiction to Twitter, so with education policy, the first step is admitting you have a problem. "You cannot search [for solutions] if you are convinced you have already found what you need" says Lant. This also means that arguments on the public-private axis (as fun as they are) are also tangential to the debate in the developing country context.

2) 'More inputs help a bit so we might as well carry on doing that for now' = not advisable 

 “Taking a placebo can be dangerous if it prevents you from seeking out the right diagnosis”. Probably enough said there.


3) Western education experts need to eat some humble pie



Usefully-named 70s band Humble Pie
"No living Western education expert has led, participated in, or lived through a truly major national improvement in measured student achievement". All currently high scoring educational systems in OECD countries already had high-scoring systems 40 years ago, so we 'over here' don't seem to know how to transform an education system either. More generally the problems for education in developing countries are (unsurprisingly) different to those in developed countries, so even with a system proven to be successful in the Netherlands, for example, we may not be any closer to our goal.





4) This isn't technical, it's incentives, it's political

The problem is in the dynamic of the system and the incentives it produces, not just a lack of a certain missing X. This reminds me of a conversation I had with a colleague when working in a school in Uganda last summer, when it dawned on us that everyone was 'playing their role' more or less effectively (teachers mostly present, pupils sat behind desks, 
adequate classrooms, timetable, register etc) but a lot of the time, nothing was actually happening. There was no learning. Pritchett's cover shows a child walking through a doorway of a façade of a school with nothing behind and this captures the point perfectly. Translating this into practical advice for someone who works for a charity trying to improve schools in developing countries (like me), when you think you've found the perfect initiative for the school, you need to ask yourself two questions: why isn’t this being done already? And why will it be done that way in the future? Incentives. And panning back out to the level of the whole system, this means politics: switching to a starfish system means ceding power and giving up central control to some measure, and there lies the difficulty.

Towards a solution...

5) There is no blueprint and there is no silver bullet

If what we are trying to do is learn the principles of design rather than how to design a particular house (Lant's metaphor), and we take into account architecture degrees are like six years (me stretching Lant's metaphor), it's clear there is no quick blueprint for success. Even within his six key characteristics for a successful system, you need these all functioning together. If you look at point 2, 'locally-operated' and think that the panacea for poor education systems is decentralisation, then you are likely to end up with a decentralised poor education system. You need all of these characteristics together, with the details right. Then adding in the inevitable caveat that political, social and educational context will determine the precise formula, and the surreal, incomprehensible bit of Zen teaching Pritchett adds in "If you should meet Buddha on the road, kill him"(?!), it's clear that there is no one formula for success.

*searching for something positive...*

6) There's loads of innovation at the micro-level, so change is possible

Particularly for those working on individual schools rather than an entire education system, take inspiration from the fact that there are plenty of actors doing great, innovative work in difficult contexts. We know that some interventions (remedial classes, curriculum reform, and others) are really effective at improving learning. The problem is more that the spider system often prevents these innovations from scaling-up.

And the irritating, super-keen development student's choice...

7) Systems-thinking is the way forward
Complex adaptive systems did this


Trying to take heed of the development ideas hype cycle and not explode with wonk-y excitement, but systems-thinking, and particularly complex adaptive systems theory, is the future. Lant has a great passage on why we're crap at thinking in terms of systems rather than agents (which is also an example of his excellent prose style) but all the cool kids in policy are talking about systems-thinking and I'll soon be blogging about it (once I've read this and this and this and this and this). Getting back to the concrete example of education, thinking in terms of systems explains why absent teachers and obstructive teachers' unions don't mean that teachers are the baddies and all we need to do is make teachers be less rubbish. If the system is set up to treat teachers like workers not professionals, and fails to provide the right incentives, then the outcomes will be inevitably be disappointing.

In conclusion, read the book because it's great and will change the way you think.

Wednesday, 5 March 2014

The Rebirth of Education (part 1): Spider vs. Starfish

As the call comes in for more money for education in developing countries, so too, does the news that current performance on education is appalling . Shockingly appalling.  If you need any more convincing, an Educational Initiatives survey covering 74% of the Indian population found that schoolchildren’s performance on conceptual questions is often worse than random guessing. Meanwhile at the current rate of improvement, Indonesian schools will take more than 1000 years to reach current OECD-country levels of quality. Other countries, at the current rate, would never get there.
Lant Pritchett’s book ‘The Rebirth of Education’ (in which a whole chapter is dedicated to crushing our spirits about education in developing countries with statistics like the last two above) attempts to explain this dire situation and what to do about it, and in doing so he kind of blew my mind. I started reading the book in part to supplement the lit. review I am currently doing for Education Partnerships Africa in which we initially aimed to find a set of basic inputs (in terms of infrastructure and resources) which would add up to a ‘good school’, and thus produce a schematic ‘blueprint’ for our partner schools. It turns out it doesn’t work that way.

Governments across the world are great at getting children physically into school. The population of labour force age in the developing world has now completed three times more years of schooling than in 1950 when 60% had no schooling at all. And in Ghana, for example, the average 7.8 years of schooling in 2010 for each child was not attained by the UK until 1970. The problem is, that the type of system which is great at sorting the logistics of schooling isn’t good at ensuring children learn. The problem is the system, meaning that 'more of the same' (= more schools, more books, more desks, more computers) won't solve the problem. 

These centralised, top-down, bureaucratic, inflexible, unresponsive, closed, ‘spider’ systems which exist across the world arose out of a mixture of demand, driven by a modernising economy (education has good returns in terms of income), but more from a drive for the ideological control of socialisation (indoctrinate those kids) and isomorphic mimicry (if we acquire the outer trappings of a responsible, well-functioning state then we seem more legitimate).  So the whole dynamic of the system has nothing to do with effective learning, and more to do with political patronage and rent-seeking in many cases; even if you assume that intentions are benevolent (strong assumption) then the spider systems just aren’t set up to deliver good education*. Pritchett even finds that ‘spider’ education systems in developing countries are value-subtracting. That is to say, as well as being more expensive than alternatives, spider systems deliver absolutely worse education than if the same teachers were teaching the same kids outside the system.

Kill that spider!
So what beats a spider in rock-paper-scissors? A starfish, you got it. Whereas in a spider system, all information across the web filters up to the brain at the centre of the web, in a starfish there is no centralised nervous system; each part is constantly taking in and processing information, and the overall movement of the starfish comes about as an aggregate of tiny little movements of each part. Translated back into education, this means a system which is
  • Open:  many different types of school and approaches allowed
  • Locally-operated: local actors have the autonomy to operate, explore and discover innovative approaches
  • Performance pressured: schools are accountable on the basis of actual, measurable learning outcomes not just schooling input
  • Professionally networked: a professional ethos among educators and organisational learning across the system facilitated and promoted
  • Technically supported: schools are equipped with the capabilities to succeed
  • Flexibly financed: finance follows students and performance with local control

Happy cause he's learning
So there we have it: Pritchett comes up with the solution? Erm, kind of. He does give a few examples of starfish systems (the US/UK higher education system; the International Baccalaureate system; Brazil’s basic education system) but this is no concrete blueprint like I was hoping for. In one of his many analogies (Pritchett’s way of explaining things, both in the book and in podcasts I’ve heard, is brilliantly lucid and witty) he likens what he is doing as not showing how to build a specific house, but giving the principles of design. Having said this, he could definitely have expanded more on the positive, starfish-side of things (five of six chapters are dedicated to taking down the current spider system), and I’m sure research/policy discussions will push on in a more practical direction, particularly as we reach 2015 and the post-MDG apocalypse.

I was going to follow that up with my impressions/key take-home messages, but this has got really long. Still haven’t got the succinctness of a pro-blogger. So I’m going to call this ‘part 1’ and write an accompanying ‘part 2’ on the ambitious assumption that people would actually read two consecutive posts of mine. In the meantime, to consolidate, gorge yourself on review/blog/blurb/podcast about the book from people more intelligent than I.

*if you’re wondering why spider systems in developed countries do a good job, Pritchett’s explanation is that they took over pre-existing local starfish systems